M10 Result

[FML|ResultsBot]

M10
ena1337
SweeT
SosoHasRedHair
WeAkUD
Download

(click to show/hide)

SweeT - 20
ena1337 - 14
SosoHasRedHair - 12
WeAkUD - 10

[FML|Renaud]

In the final moment of the game, ena1337 was desync, resulting in him winning in his version, and SweeT winning in the version of everyone else.

We decided to handle it the same way we would with a disconnect, and so Sweet wins.

However we decided to give ena the top score, since at the time of the desync (that we are counting as a disconnect) his score was much higher. Even after Sweet gained a lot of xp from forcing him to TP and killing SosoHasRedHair, ena still had top score (but by a smaller margin).

[ZsSuperCumulo]

 

[ena1337]

No permission  to download the replay. May I get the replay so I can compare final points? I felt like I shouldve had maximum points due to hero score. I might be wrong tho, thats why I would like to check your version of the replay.

[aarnikratti]

Though Sweet would not have got the top score if ena would have disconnected conventional way, now he got all the experience from ena's units and heroes.

Tricky case, though.

EDIT:
Ena, you can download the replay here:
http://ffam.rusdota.net/gameinfo/?rdr=1&id=213

[SweeT]

You realize I killed sh and he only had 37 food left BEFORE he desynced? And if he didn't desync I would have chased the rest of his army... I really don't think he could have won even if he stayed. How could he fight 100 pop with no sh? On his version my army just went afk and stopped chasing his tc and rest of it

[aarnikratti]

You realize I killed sh and he only had 37 food left BEFORE he desynced? And if he didn't desync I would have chased the rest of his army... I really don't think he could have won even if he stayed. How could he fight 100 pop with no sh? On his version my army just went afk and stopped chasing his tc and rest of it

I watched the replay and he actually desynced before he lost SH. I didnt say he would have won, I just said that he would have retained his top score if he had disconnected (not desynced). And now admins are equating this deync to disconnect, that's why i mentioned that top score thing.

[ZsSuperCumulo]

why do people get dsync?. The two times it happened to be was because some obs were lagging and right after that I just got disconnected...

[ena1337]

why do people get dsync?. The two times it happened to be was because some obs were lagging and right after that I just got disconnected...

I guess because of crossrealm dysfunction between BNet and w3arena... maybe it wouldn't be as bad, if the bot would be connected to iccup.com and I would use the iccup.com client instead of bnet.

[FML|Renaud]

I'll update the replay in a sec, and I'll talk about it in the admin section, you definitely had a much higher score when you desync

[FML|Renaud]

We decided to give ena the top score, since at the time of the desync (that we are counting as a disconnect) his score was much higher. Even after Sweet gained a lot of xp from forcing him to TP and killing SosoHasRedHair, ena still had top score (but by a smaller margin).

[ZsSuperCumulo]

lol, at this rate ena will be in semifinals with no problem 

[ena1337]

PUSH IT TO THE LIMIT

thanks FML community for being so eloberative on the case ... and sorry for me being a complicated dude with my w3a ban issues ... :S

[SweeT]

Wow renaud, what ever happened to "we treat as a normal disc"

I feel like ena is lucky to get sympathy points here,

[FML|Mog]

Wow renaud, what ever happened to "we treat as a normal disc"

I feel like ena is lucky to get sympathy points here,

If they treat as a normal disconnect, then ena gets +2 points for top score. Which is what they are doing...